Cooking

We Cooked and Ranked Every Fish

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr



We Cooked and Ranked Every Fish

We bought 45 different British fish, cooked every single one, and ranked them from S tier to F tier. The cheapest cost nothing at all. The most expensive was £40 a kilo.

We started at a UK fish market and worked from the bottom up — dogfish that Cornish crews give to the crabs, through the sardines and mackerel and the ones nobody has heard of, all the way to turbot. We cooked every fish the way we’d actually cook it in the restaurants: some on the bone, some filleted, some over charcoal, some battered and fried.
A few things we learned. Coley is as good as cod and costs less. Megrim sole got renamed Cornish sole because nobody buys a fish with “grim” in it. Gurnard is named after the French for “grunt,” because they grunt when you pull them out of the water. Blue shark reabsorbs its own urine, which you can taste. And one of the fish we ranked turned out not to be the fish we thought it was at all, which meant disqualifying it after the fact.

Six fish made S tier. At the end, we picked our favourites blind and didn’t agree.

VIDEO CHAPTERS
00:00 – We Cooked All The Fish
00:21 – Dogfish £0
01:42 – Sardine £4
02:30 – Scad £5
03:13 – Triggerfish £5
04:18 – Whitebait £5
05:22 – Herring £5.50
06:33 – Grey mullet £7
07:40 – Pouting £7
08:44 – Conger eel £7
10:12 – Blue shark £7
11:30 – Anchovy £7
12:29 – Mackerel £7.50
13:57 – Megrim Sole £8
15:50 – “Lumpfish” £8
16:43 – Dab £8
17:29 – Garfish £8.50
18:29 – Cuckoo Ray £8.99
19:46 – Whiting £9
20:57 – Ling £9
21:32 – Plaice £9
22:31 – Weever £9.35
23:39 – Blonde Ray £9.50
24:37 – Gurnard £10
26:13 – Coley £10.50
27:19 – Sea trout £11.50
29:54 – Witch £11.95
31:08 – Hake £12
32:19 – Haddock £12
33:35 – Red bream £12.90
34:26 – Pollock £13
35:54 – Salmon £13.50
37:17 – Cod £14
38:19 – Skate wing £15.50
39:24 – Lemon sole £16
40:44 – Gilthead bream £16.75
42:40 – Bluefin tuna £18.55
44:04 – Monkfish £19
45:43 – Halibut £19.95
47:33 – Wild sea bass £20
49:51 – Brill £24
50:47 – John Dory £24
52:26 – Pink bream £30
53:39 – Red mullet £30
55:58 – Dover sole £36
58:06 – Turbot £40

25 Comments

  1. Should put the name of the fish on the image of the tierlist too, I cant remember or tell which fish is what rated at the end.

  2. Best cooking vid ever! The amount of information….and just plain fun cannot be measured. I'm now on a fish journey of my own.

  3. Be curious on your thoughts on Tang fish, Which I first had in Hawaii, lots of people keep them as pets in aquariums but out there they are eaten.

  4. haveyou mixed up haddock and pollock in the video? Isn't haddock the one with the black dot on the side and not pollock 34:00? 🤔

  5. Dogfish is a shark, and you need to treat it differently to cook. It holds urea in the flesh, so it tastes like piss, if not prepared correctly.

  6. Solo a un inglés se le puede ocurrir tirar la cabeza del rape o decir que el cazón está malo, el problema de los ingleses es que ni saben cocinar ni menos apreciar lo que es bueno. Miedo me da pensar que tengáis un restaurante, aunque pensándolo mejor como los ingleses solo les gusta comer mierda os puede valer.

  7. I love the Fallow Gents but watching them cook these fish was painful. How they cooked the dog fish and shark was criminal.

  8. Wow, I cannot believe how cheap all of those fish are. here in Bend, OR, Halibut is $75 a kilo. Or $35 a lb.

  9. I was surprised the gave Monkfish a lower rating. By far my favourite fish. It's like Beef Steak in texture and takes on so much flavour when roasted. I love it with Rosemary and garlic.

  10. My summer childhood memory in ireland – after coming home when my dad caught mackerel and we drove straight home to cook. Went to our tiny garden to get the rest of the ingredients freshly picked young garden peas in butter, freshly dug new spuds steamed in their soft skins with cream and chives and hour old mackerel fried hard on both sides until its caramel brown and crispy, with plenty of salt. Never had a meal as good since.

  11. we eat shark in Australia BUT it has to be prepared propperly . it usually cut different to that ( but not always). so.. we use larger fillets and cut them "top to bottom" like a steak but also on a steep angle "head to tail " dont know how to explain that better sorry. we also freeze it to get rid of the amonia smell and taste and then we batter them and deep fry them , we call it flake

Write A Comment