Celebrity Chefs

Chef John Manion Is Bringing A New Kind Of Steakhouse To The West Loop With Palomino

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

WEST LOOP — Chef John Manion is bringing another live-fire restaurant to Chicago, this time paying homage to the American West.

Palomino, slated to open in early 2027, will be a “distinctly American” steakhouse that challenges Chicago’s traditional steakhouse model, Manion said in an interview. The restaurant will open in the location that was formerly Proxi, 565 W. Randolph St., which closed last year.

Palomino will combine Manion’s signature live-fire cooking, drawing inspiration from the American South and West, particularly Texas, Oklahoma, California and the Gulf Coast.

“I hope to kind of shatter people’s expectations a bit by what we’re presenting,” Manion said.

The concept grew out of the pandemic, when Manion said he worried about the future of his career and began experimenting with outdoor cooking. He commissioned a portable grilling rig and began cooking steaks outdoors at events and catering gigs, later traveling to festivals across the country.

Chef John Manion cutting meat. Credit: Provided

In 2021, Manion helped his “good friend” Will Duncan open Babygold Barbecue in suburban Berwyn. Having conversations with chefs and barbecue enthusiasts from across the country introduced him to various American cooking traditions, inspiring the concept for Palomino.

What he learned will show up in how he grills meats at Palomino, incorporating American smoking techniques, including slow-cooking steaks over wood before finishing them on the grill.

Manion has recruited Carlos Cruz, formerly of John’s Food and Wine, to lead the kitchen and Melody Arnold, a longtime collaborator who previously worked at Manion’s restaurants El Che and most recently Brasero in West Town. Manion credits Arnold for Brasero’s sweet potato, which he says can “never change.”

Manion praised Cruz’s intuitive and intellectual approach to cooking, particularly his ability to experiment with flavors and plating. He was equally enthusiastic about Arnold, who he described as the “steadiest of steady cooks” and “just unshakable.”

Palomino’s menu is still under development, but Manion shared one dish he’s planning to feature: quail stuffed with homemade duck sausage. The dish is served over white beans, charred and marinated radicchio and poblano salsa verde.

The team is still experimenting with how to prepare the quail, including slow roasting, smoking and finishing on the grill.

“That dish is gonna be on the menu and you know, for how good it is right now, I can’t wait to see where we end up. But it’s pretty phenomenal,” Manion said.

For the rest of the meat on the menu, expect American-sourced beef, duck, quail, pheasant and rabbit.

Chef John Manion has launched pop-up Argentinian markets inside El Che Steakhouse. Credit: Provided

Palomino will also have a raw bar drawing inspiration from Manion’s childhood visits to Florida seafood shacks and his later experiences eating in Houston and New Orleans. Rather than relying on traditional East Coast seafood accompaniments, Manion hopes to incorporate Mexican, Texan and Gulf Coast flavors, including elements like comeback sauce.

“Let’s make the baseline delicious and bold, but we can kind of go from there,” Manion said.

The bar program, led by longtime Hey Che Hospitality team leader Alex Cuper, will feature a 100 percent American-made wine list and source American spirits for its cocktails.

Manion hopes to emphasize the former Proxi’s existing 17-foot-tall windows and make the existing open-fire hearth a focal point along with a custom smoker from Lockhart, Texas.

“It’s going to be lighter, brighter. It’s not going to be dark, heavy like a lot of when you think of when you think of a steakhouse,” Manion said. “We’ve been working with some artists that we really enjoy. … I don’t think it’s gonna look like anything else in Chicago.”

Manion is working with Chicago design firm Siren Betty to transform the space, which will accommodate about 150 diners. Construction is expected to wrap up around mid-December, with an opening between mid-January and early March.

______________________________________________________________________

Support Local News!

Subscribe to Block Club Chicago, an independent, 501(c)(3), journalist-run newsroom. Every dime we make funds reporting from Chicago’s neighborhoods. Already subscribe? Click here to gift a subscription, or you can support Block Club with a tax-deductible donation.

Listen to the Block Club Chicago podcast:

Write A Comment